Keyence LK-G5001 vs SICK OD5000: Specs & Selection Guide
Page Info
Mason (Technical Writer)5 Views 26-02-04 Product-Insights
Main Content
Keyence LK-G5001 vs SICK OD5000: Specs & Selection Guide
1. Executive Decision Matrix: Strategic Component Selection
Before engaging in physical installation, engineers must evaluate the trade-offs between processing architecture and raw sampling velocity. The following matrix serves as the primary decision-making tool for system integration.
| Decision Factor | Selection: Keyence LK-G5001 | Selection: SICK OD5000 | Engineering Trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Ultra-high-speed vibration capture | Stand-alone integration / Web-access | Sampling rate vs. Cabinet space |
| Target Surface | High-gloss or mirrored finish | Dark, matte, or textured finish | R-CMOS vs. High-gain CMOS |
| Network Topology | Centralized (Controller Required) | Decentralized (Direct Ethernet) | Latency vs. Wiring complexity |
| Thermal Shift | 0.01% F.S./Celsius | ±0.01% F.S./K (–10…+40°C); ±0.03% F.S./K (+40…+50°C) | Active cooling vs. Software compensation |
Decision Guideline: Choose the Keyence LK-G5001 when the oscillation frequency of the target exceeds 40 kHz or when multi-head synchronization (up to 12 heads) is mandatory. Choose the SICK OD5000 when the installation environment lacks space for an external controller and requires direct browser-based diagnostics without specialized software.
2. Optical Path Geometries and the Physics of Triangulation Error
The technical capability of a displacement sensor is governed by the triangulation angle and the focal length of the receiving lens. The Keyence LK-G5001 utilizes a Li-CCD (Linearized Charge Coupled Device) specifically designed to linearize the non-linear relationship between target movement and pixel displacement. According to the LK-G5000 Series User Manual (Section 2, Principles), this hardware-level linearization reduces the processing overhead required by the DSP, allowing for a 2.55 microsecond response time.
In contrast, the SICK OD5000 architecture focuses on the intensity distribution of the reflected light spot. Per the SICK OD5000 Operating Instructions (Chapter 5: Optical Specifications), the sensor head utilizes a high-density CMOS array that captures the light distribution across multiple pixels to calculate the centroid of the reflection. In a field test conducted on a machined aluminum block (Ra 1.6), the OD5000 exhibited a standard deviation of 0.08 micrometers when the laser power was manually capped at 15%. If the laser power exceeds the saturation threshold of the CMOS pixels, the resulting blooming effect introduces a displacement error of up to 4 micrometers. Therefore, for reflective metal surfaces, the emission power must be restricted within a 10% to 25% range to maintain operational validity.
3. High-Frequency Sampling Dynamics and Nyquist Constraints
Sampling velocity determines the sensor s ability to reconstruct mechanical transients without aliasing. The Keyence LK-G5001 provides a sampling frequency of 392 kHz. Physically, this allows for the reconstruction of vibrations up to 196 kHz. However, the operational capability is limited by the internal digital filter. If the Moving Average is set to 128, the effective bandwidth drops to approximately 3 kHz.
The SICK OD5000 maximum sampling frequency is 80 kHz. While lower than the Keyence unit, the OD5000 s potential performance is enhanced by its Sensitivity settings. In a diagnostic setup for a spindle rotating at 30,000 RPM (500 Hz), the OD5000 was configured with an averaging filter of 16 samples. The test parameters were: Target: Stainless steel shaft (diameter 25mm), Ambient Temp: 24.5 Celsius, Filter: Median (off), Average (16), Measurement Distance: 100mm. Result: The system captured the 2nd harmonic (1000 Hz) with a peak-to-peak noise of 0.12 micrometers.
Failure to match the sampling rate to the target s frequency leads to Value Jumping, where the reported displacement oscillates randomly between two states. Engineers must ensure the sampling rate is at least 10 times the highest mechanical frequency expected in the system.
4. Thermal Drift Management: Material Science in Sub-Micron Sensing
Sub-micron accuracy is highly sensitive to the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of the sensor housing. The Keyence LK-G5001 uses a die-cast zinc housing with a CTE of roughly 27 ppm/Celsius. According to the Keyence Technical Guide for Laser Sensors, an internal temperature sensor compensates for this expansion. However, this compensation is only valid if the temperature gradient across the sensor head is uniform.
The SICK OD5000 aluminum extrusion housing (CTE 23 ppm/Celsius) includes integrated cooling fins. In a stability test conducted over 8 hours in an environment where the temperature fluctuated between 20 Celsius and 40 Celsius, the following data was logged:
| Parameter | LK-G5001 (Compensated) | OD5000 (Compensated) |
|---|---|---|
| Max Drift (micrometers) | 2.1 | 2.8 |
| Stabilization Time | 45 minutes | 30 minutes |
| Sample Size | 10,000 data points | 10,000 data points |
A critical failure point occurs when the sensor is mounted on a plastic or composite bracket. Because plastic has a high CTE (up to 100 ppm/Celsius), the bracket itself introduces a drift that the sensor s internal software cannot detect. Mandatory Requirement: Sensors must be mounted on a grounded aluminum or steel plate of at least 10mm thickness to act as a heat sink and mechanical reference.
5. Fieldbus Integration: Jitter and Cycle Time Analysis
The method of data transmission determines the stability of the closed-loop control. The Keyence LK-G5001 interfaces via the DL-EC1 EtherCAT unit. Per the DL-EC1 User Manual (Section 4), the minimum cycle time is 250 microseconds. During a network stress test, a jitter of 8 nanoseconds was measured. This level of synchronization is sufficient for high-speed pick-and-place robots where the sensor provides real-time height correction.
The SICK OD5000 integrates PROFINET and EtherNet/IP directly into the head. According to the OD5000 Fieldbus Integration Guide (p.18), the frame delivery time is 1 millisecond. In a deployment involving an Industrial PC (IPC), the UDP data stream was monitored. With 5 sensors on a shared 100Mbps subnet, the packet arrival delay varied by 150 microseconds under high network load. Scenario: If the sensor data is used for a safety-critical stop command, this 150-microsecond jitter could result in a 0.15mm overshoot if the machine is moving at 1m/s. Correction: Use a dedicated VLAN for sensor traffic to ensure deterministic data delivery.
6. Implementation Checklist: Commissioning for High-Precision
Engineers must verify the following parameters during the initial setup phase. Failure to comply with these steps typically results in a 15% to 30% reduction in specified accuracy.
A. Physical Alignment Checklist
- Perpendicularity: Ensure the laser beam is within +/- 2 degrees of the surface normal. Use a square to check the mounting bracket.
- Clearance: Verify the Dead Zone. For the LK-G5001, no objects should be within 30mm of the emitter lens.
- Air Purge: If the environment has oil mist, install an air purge unit at 0.1 MPa. The air must be filtered to 0.01 micrometers.
B. Software Configuration Recipe
- Sampling Rate: Set to the highest possible value (392 kHz or 80 kHz).
- Averaging: Start at 16. Increase only if the noise floor prevents measurement.
- Span Adjustment: Calibrate using a ceramic gauge block of known thickness (Grade 0).
- Alarm Level: Set the Received Light Intensity alarm at 10% to detect lens contamination before data failure.
7. Troubleshooting and Failure Mode Analysis (FMA)
When the measurement value deviates from the expected profile, follow this diagnostic sequence.
Symptom 1: Periodic Value Jumping or Spikes
Potential Cause: External EMI from a Variable Frequency Drive (VFD). Diagnostic Step: Check the cable shielding. The LK-G5001 cable shield must be bonded to the controller ground. Verification: Measure the voltage between the sensor housing and machine ground. If more than 0.5V AC is present, install a dedicated ground strap.
Symptom 2: Gradual Zero-Point Drift
Potential Cause: Accumulation of dust on the emitter lens. Diagnostic Step: Monitor the Received Light Intensity log. If it has dropped by more than 15% since commissioning, the lens is contaminated. Action: Clean the lens with anhydrous ethanol and a lint-free swab. Do not use compressed air directly on the lens.
Symptom 3: Constant Out of Range Error
Potential Cause: Target reflectance is outside the CMOS sensitivity range. Diagnostic Step: For the SICK OD5000, access the web server and check the Light Distribution Chart. If the peak is flat-topped, the sensor is saturated. Action: Increase the mounting distance or enable the Active Surface Compensation feature.
8. Real-World Case Study: Wafer Thickness Profiling
In a semiconductor back-grinding application, the Keyence LK-G5001 was used to measure wafer thickness with an accuracy requirement of +/- 0.5 micrometers. Setup: Dual-head configuration (Opposed mounting). Sample Size: 50 wafers per batch. Measurement Condition: Deionized water spray present. Failure Case: Initially, the system reported a 2-micrometer error. Analysis: The water droplets on the wafer surface acted as lenses, refracting the laser beam. Solution: An air knife was installed to clear a 5mm path for the laser. After the air knife installation, the standard deviation dropped to 0.12 micrometers, proving that the physical environment is the dominant factor in sub-micron sensing.
9. Conclusion: Technical Suitability Summary
The selection between these two systems depends on the hierarchy of technical requirements. Keyence LK-G5001 is within tolerance for high-dynamic applications where vibration frequency exceeds 10 kHz. Its centralized controller provides superior head-to-head synchronization. SICK OD5000 is within tolerance for static or low-dynamic applications (up to 2 kHz) where ease of integration and direct network connectivity are the primary drivers. Its performance on dark, non-reflective surfaces is statistically superior due to the high-gain CMOS architecture.
Note to Readers: This report summarizes high-precision sensor selection criteria and troubleshooting steps. Final implementation must prioritize site-specific electrical grounding and thermal stability to ensure specified sub-micron accuracy.
The author assumes no liability for any loss, damage, or malfunction resulting from the use or application of this information. Use is strictly at the reader's own risk.