SICK W4S-3 Inox vs KEYENCE PZ-G: Wiring Guide for Photoelectric Sensors

---

1. Introduction to Sensor Integration in Tough Environments

Industrial automation relies heavily on photoelectric sensors for reliable object detection, yet the performance of these devices is only as strong as the integrity of their installation and wiring. For technical personnel, this means going beyond simply matching wire colors; it requires a deep understanding of output types, noise immunity, and environmental resilience.

The SICK W4S-3 Inox and the KEYENCE PZ-G series represent two distinct approaches to achieving high-reliability sensing. The SICK W4S-3 Inox, with its stainless steel (316L) washdown housing and IP69K rating, is a common sight in food, beverage, and pharmaceutical facilities, where resistance to harsh cleaning agents is paramount. Conversely, the KEYENCE PZ-G is renowned for its ease of use, simple setup, and high-speed detection in general industrial and packaging applications. This guide will navigate the crucial wiring and installation differences that define successful deployment for each sensor in the field.

---

2. Core Wiring Architecture: PNP vs. NPN Output Logic

The first critical decision in any sensor installation is the output configuration, which dictates how the sensor interfaces with the controlling device, typically a Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) input card. For DC 3-wire sensors like the SICK W4S-3 and KEYENCE PZ-G, the two primary configurations are PNP (Sourcing) and NPN (Sinking).

2.1. Understanding Sourcing (PNP) and Sinking (NPN) Outputs

Most industrial components adhere to the following wire color standards for DC 3-wire sensors:

• Brown: +DC Supply (L+)
• Blue: -DC Supply/Ground (L-)
• Black: Output Signal

Output Feature	Sourcing (PNP)	Sinking (NPN)
Output State (Object Detected)	Switches to L+ (Positive Voltage, e.g., +24 V)	Switches to L- (Ground Potential, 0 V)
Current Flow	Current sources (flows out) from the sensor, through the load, to the ground.	Current sinks (flows in) to the sensor from the load, connecting to the ground.
Load Connection	Load is connected between the sensor output (Black) and L- (Blue).	Load is connected between the sensor output (Black) and L+ (Brown).
Regional Preference Context	Predominant in Europe and often considered the safer choice in automation.	Common in North America and some Asian markets.

The SICK W4S-3 Inox (WTT4S-3P2161A01) typically uses a PNP output, reflecting the standard preference in European machinery and washdown-intensive environments. The KEYENCE PZ-G series, such as the PZ-G61N, is available in both PNP and NPN, providing flexibility based on the PLC input card’s design (Sinking input requires a PNP sensor, Sourcing input requires an NPN sensor).

2.2. A Field Technician’s Perspective on Wiring Selection

When commissioning a new machine, a technician often faces the dilemma of choosing the correct sensor type.

• If the PLC input card is Sinking (most common in Europe): You must select a PNP sensor (like the SICK W4S-3 Inox). This is because the PLC input is waiting for a positive voltage to turn on.
• If the PLC input card is Sourcing: You must select an NPN sensor (common in some older or specialized systems). The PLC input provides the positive voltage and is waiting for the sensor to complete the circuit to ground.

A technical experience suggests that PNP sensors are generally preferred in high-risk environments because if the output wire (Black) accidentally shorts to the machine chassis (ground/L-), the output will not energize, thus avoiding unintended machine operation. Conversely, with an NPN sensor, an accidental short to ground would immediately trigger the output, creating a potential safety hazard.

---

3. Physical Installation: Mounting, Alignment, and Environmental Resilience

The physical installation strategy for the W4S-3 and PZ-G differs significantly due to their primary target applications.

3.1. SICK W4S-3 Inox: Washdown and Hygienic Mounting

The W4S-3 Inox is engineered for survival. Its stainless steel (V4A/316L) housing and IP69K rating demand installation practices that maintain the integrity of the hygienic design.

• Mounting Technique: The sensor typically mounts using through-holes in the stainless steel body. The key is to use stainless steel fasteners and certified hygienic mounting brackets (e.g., SICK’s BEF-W4-B series) that minimize crevices where contaminants or cleaning agents can accumulate.
• Cable Glands and Entry: The factory-installed cable or M12 connector (often 4-pin) must be sealed against high-pressure washdowns. Technicians should ensure the cable run exits the washdown zone as soon as possible and that any cable glands or conduits used are also IP69K rated and correctly torqued to prevent moisture ingress.
• Alignment Adjustment: Many W4S-3 models feature a metal membrane teach button on the housing. This sealed design is crucial. Instead of using a traditional trimmer, the technician must follow a specific teach-in routine (e.g., place target, press button, remove target, press button) for automatic sensitivity adjustment. This process, while sealed, requires careful attention to the small status LEDs for confirmation.

3.2. KEYENCE PZ-G: Ease of Use and Rapid Deployment

The PZ-G series emphasizes rapid installation and simplicity, making it ideal for standard factory environments.

• Mounting Technique: The PZ-G offers high mounting flexibility: rectangular models often use tool-free, one-touch mounting brackets that snap the sensor into place, while threaded models use standard M18 nuts. This one-touch system significantly cuts down on installation time.
• Sensitivity and Mode Adjustment: Unlike the sealed teach-in of the SICK, the PZ-G typically uses a sensitivity adjustment trimmer (potentiometer) and a separate switch for LIGHT-ON/DARK-ON mode selection.
• Field Tip (Adjustment): A common sequence is to position the target, adjust the trimmer until the output LED turns on (Position A), remove the target, and adjust again until the output LED just turns off (Position B), and then set the trimmer halfway between A and B for maximum stability (margin). This process provides a clear, visual method for setting the sensing range.

---

4. Advanced Electrical Immunity: Shielding and Grounding Best Practices

In both high-speed packaging lines (KEYENCE environment) and electrically noisy food processing plants (SICK environment), signal integrity is critical. Proper grounding and shielding techniques differentiate a reliable installation from one plagued by intermittent faults.

4.1. Cable Shielding for Sensor Signal Integrity

The purpose of a shielded cable is to create a Faraday cage around the signal wires to protect them from Electromagnetic Interference (EMI) caused by variable frequency drives (VFDs), large motors, or welding equipment.

• Best Practice: The cable shield (drain wire) should only be connected to ground at one end. This single-point grounding prevents the shield itself from becoming a conductor for noise current (a ground loop).
• Recommendation: For DC 3-wire sensors, the shield should be connected to the system's master ground point or the PLC cabinet’s clean ground bus bar. Never connect the shield to the sensor's metal housing or to both ends of the cable.
• Field Application: In SICK W4S-3 installations where high-pressure washdown is a concern, the use of specialized M12 connectors and cables designed for hygienic zones (often blue, TPE jacketed) is common. These cables often feature a foil and braid shield combination to withstand both mechanical stress and environmental noise.

4.2. Minimizing Common Mode Noise and Ground Loops

A ground loop occurs when there is more than one path to ground, creating a potential difference that causes current to flow in the signal circuit, leading to noise.

• Technical Guideline: Ensure the sensor power supply’s negative terminal (L-) is connected to the control cabinet’s common/reference ground. This is the only acceptable connection point.
• Troubleshooting Experience: If a sensor repeatedly gives false detections when a large motor starts, the first step is to verify the shield is grounded at the panel end and floating at the sensor end. A field engineer will often use an oscilloscope to check the L- (Blue wire) signal relative to the true ground to look for noise spikes, indicating a poor grounding path.

---

5. Operational Depth: The Critical Role of Light/Dark Switching Modes

Both the SICK W4S-3 and the KEYENCE PZ-G offer LIGHT-ON (L.ON) and DARK-ON (D.ON) operating modes, which define the sensor’s output state relative to the received light. The correct mode selection can simplify PLC logic and prevent complex programming.

5.1. Defining the Switching Modes

• LIGHT-ON (L.ON): The output is ON when light is received (sensor beam is clear). The output is OFF when the target is detected (sensor beam is blocked).
• DARK-ON (D.ON): The output is ON when light is not received (target is detected/beam is blocked). The output is OFF when the beam is clear.

5.2. Practical Decision Flow for Mode Selection

A seasoned technician will select the mode that causes the output to be ON during the critical machine state or the most infrequent event.

Application Type	Recommended Mode	Reasoning
Object Counter on a Conveyor	DARK-ON	The output is ON only for the brief moment the product blocks the beam, simplifying the PLC counting logic.
Safety Guard Confirmation (Through-beam)	LIGHT-ON	The output is ON when the area is clear. If the beam is blocked (unintended intrusion) or if the sensor fails (loses light), the output turns OFF, signaling an alert state (Fail-Safe logic).
Retro-reflective Detection of Clear Film (SICK)	LIGHT-ON	The sensor is typically set to detect the reflector. The output stays ON until the film breaks the polarized beam.

Both SICK and KEYENCE provide a physical switch or a teach-in option to select the mode. For the PZ-G series, a physical toggle switch on the back of the sensor allows the technician to select L.ON or D.ON instantly, offering superior flexibility during on-the-fly modifications.

---

6. Technical Feature Comparison for Installation Context

This table details the technical specifications most relevant to the installation and wiring process for the standard models of the SICK W4S-3 Inox and the KEYENCE PZ-G, enabling technical personnel to make informed choices based on environmental demands.

Feature Context	SICK W4S-3 Inox (WTT4S-3P2161A01 - Example)	KEYENCE PZ-G (PZ-G61N - Example)
Housing Material / Rating	Stainless Steel (316L), IP66/IP67/IP68/IP69K	Glass-Fiber Reinforced PBT, IP67
Primary Connection Type	M12 Connector (4-pin) or Pre-Wired Cable	Pre-Wired Cable (2m) or M8/M12 Connector
Output Type	PNP (Common standard for hygienic zones)	NPN or PNP (Model dependent, offering flexibility)
Max Output Current	less than or equal to 100 mA	less than or equal to 100 mA
Switching Frequency	Up to 1,000 Hz	Up to 1,000 Hz (500 microsecond response time)
Sensitivity Adjustment	Sealed Teach-In Button (Protected against washdown)	1-Turn Trimmer (Potentiometer)
Washdown Consideration	Designed for chemical and high-pressure cleaning resistance.	Standard industrial rating; not ideal for prolonged high-pressure spray.

---

7. Power Distribution and Load Considerations in Sensor Arrays

When installing a large array of sensors, such as 50 units on an assembly line, the collective power consumption and the stability of the power supply become major installation factors.

7.1. Sizing the DC Power Supply

While a single SICK W4S-3 or KEYENCE PZ-G sensor draws a low current (typically less than or equal to 30 mA without load), an array can quickly strain the power supply (PSU).

• Calculation: If 50 sensors are installed, the minimum power supply current capacity required (at 24 V DC) is 50 x 0.03 A = 1.5 A (no-load). However, the PLC input card, I/O modules, and any connected loads must be factored in.
• Technical Rule of Thumb: Field experience dictates that the PSU capacity should be rated for at least 1.5 to 2 times the calculated total continuous load to handle inrush current from multiple devices switching simultaneously and to ensure the PSU operates below its thermal limits for longevity.

7.2. Voltage Drop Management over Long Cable Runs

Long cable runs (e.g., over 50 meters) can introduce a significant voltage drop, where the voltage received at the sensor is below the minimum operating voltage (around 10 V DC).

• Mitigation: To combat this, technicians should select larger gauge wire (smaller AWG number). For most industrial applications, 22 AWG or 20 AWG is standard. If the run is exceptionally long, a 18 AWG cable is warranted, or, preferably, the use of a remote I/O block to localize the power source closer to the sensor cluster.
• Sensor Reliability Check: If a sensor is failing intermittently, especially during cold startup or under maximum load, the first troubleshooting step is to measure the actual DC voltage at the sensor’s connector (between Brown and Blue wires). If it drops below the specified minimum (e.g., 10 V DC), cable resistance is the likely culprit, demanding thicker wire or a power source repositioning.

---

8. Advanced Sensing Techniques: Background Suppression and Polarization

The installation challenge often involves maximizing the reliability of detection, which necessitates understanding and correctly utilizing the sensor’s built-in optical features: background suppression (BGS) and polarization filtering.

8.1. Background Suppression (BGS) Configuration in the Field

Background Suppression is a crucial feature, standard in many photoelectric sensors, including advanced SICK and KEYENCE models. It allows the sensor to reliably detect an object placed in front of a shiny or cluttered background without being falsely triggered by the reflection from the background.

• Mechanism: BGS sensors use two receiving elements (or a position-sensitive detector, PSD) to measure the angle of the reflected light. Light reflected from the target (closer object) hits one element, while light reflected from the background (farther object) hits the other.
• Installation Implication: The technical challenge during installation is setting the cutoff distance (Sdmax).
• Field Tip: When setting the range for a KEYENCE PZ-G BGS model, the technician must ensure the sensing distance is set slightly less than the distance to the background surface. If the set distance is too close to the background, the sensor can become unstable. For critical applications, SICK’s BGS sensors often provide a more precise, programmable teach-in feature allowing for finer control over the exact point where the background is ignored.
• Why it Matters: In an application using the SICK W4S-3 Inox on a stainless steel conveyor belt (which is highly reflective), a standard diffuse sensor would fail constantly. A BGS sensor is essential here, and the installation must ensure the background surface is positioned safely outside the determined sensing range.

8.2. Leveraging Polarization for Reflective Target Detection

Retro-reflective sensors utilize a reflector to bounce the light back to the sensor. However, detecting shiny or clear targets (like shrink wrap, plastic bottles, or polished metal parts) can be difficult because the target itself acts like a mirror, reflecting the light directly back to the sensor even when the beam is interrupted. This causes a false "clear beam" signal.

• Polarization Filter Solution: Both SICK and KEYENCE retro-reflective sensors employ polarization filters to solve this. The sensor emits light polarized in one plane (e.g., vertical). The reflector uses a corner-cube design that rotates the light by 90 degrees (to horizontal) before sending it back. The sensor's receiver only accepts the 90 degrees rotated light.
• Wiring and Installation Criterion:
• 1. Reflector Orientation: The reflector must be correctly installed. For KEYENCE PZ-G models, ensuring the sensor's lens and the reflector's surface are perfectly parallel is crucial for successful 90 degrees light rotation.
• 2. Target Integrity: If the target is a highly reflective surface, ensure that the straight-reflected light (which has not been rotated) is absorbed or deflected and does not return to the receiver.
• Practical Example: When installing a SICK retro-reflective sensor (like the W4S-3) to detect clear plastic trays, the technician must verify that the sensor does not see the tray when it is present. If the tray is present and the sensor still sees the reflector, the polarization filter is not working effectively, or the tray is too thin to adequately depolarize the light beam.

---

9. Interfacing with Control Systems: Data Mapping and Diagnostics

The installation process is not complete until the sensor’s signal is correctly mapped and interpreted by the PLC or control system.

9.1. Mapping Sensor Status to PLC Memory

For the field technician, the goal is to make the signal straightforward for the controls programmer.

• Discrete Input Assignment: The sensor's Black output wire is connected to a specific discrete input channel on the PLC. Standard practice is to assign meaningful tag names (e.g., PZ_G61N_Conveyor_Start_Detect) that clearly indicate the sensor’s physical location and function.
• Signal Debouncing: High-speed sensors, particularly the KEYENCE PZ-G, can switch incredibly fast (up to 1,000 Hz). If the PLC input is read too quickly, mechanical vibration or slight movement of the target can cause multiple triggers (chattering). A technician must communicate the sensor type to the programmer, who should implement a software filter (debouncing) with a time constant (e.g., 5 ms to 10 ms) in the PLC logic to ensure a stable signal.

9.2. Utilizing Diagnostic Feedback from Sensor LEDs

Both SICK and KEYENCE sensors incorporate status LEDs, which are the technician's primary diagnostic tool in the absence of a multimeter or laptop.

• Output LED (Orange/Yellow): Indicates the state of the Black output wire. If the output is ON, this LED is lit. This is used to verify the correct operation mode (L.ON/D.ON) and to set the sensitivity.
• Stability/Signal Strength LED (Green/Red): This LED is critical for alignment.
• Optimal Alignment (Experience-Based): A solid green or strong signal indication means the sensor is receiving light reliably. If the LED is flashing green or turns red, it signifies a low margin or poor alignment. A technician should never leave an installation where this LED is anything but solid green (or the strongest indicator color) for long-term reliability.
• SICK Example: The W4S-3 series often includes a margin indicator that lights up more intensely as the signal quality improves, allowing the technician to manually adjust the mounting angle to maximize the received light and ensure a large operating reserve.

---

10. Wiring Termination Integrity: Connectors and Strain Relief

The most common failure point in an industrial electrical system is the terminal or connector, particularly where vibration or moisture is present.

10.1. M12 Connector Installation and Torque

Many high-specification sensors, including the SICK W4S-3 Inox, use M12 connectors for their ruggedness and seal integrity.

• Sealing: The M12 connection relies on an internal O-ring seal. When installing the mating cable, the technician must confirm the O-ring is present, undamaged, and that the plastic or metal coupling nut is correctly torqued. Over-torquing can damage the threads or deform the O-ring, leading to leaks, especially in a washdown environment. Under-torquing is the most common cause of moisture ingress.
• Field Inspection: If a sensor fails intermittently in a washdown area, the first step is often to unscrew the M12 connection, check for any condensation or corrosion inside the threads, and replace the connector if any moisture damage is observed.

10.2. Managing Cable Strain and Flexing

Sensor cables are often subjected to repeated flexing, particularly on moving machine parts.

• Strain Relief: The cable must be secured near the sensor housing to prevent strain on the internal connection points. Using cable ties to anchor the cable to a stationary structure within 10 cm of the sensor is standard practice.
• Cable Grade: For applications involving continuous flexing (e.g., on a robot arm or slide mechanism), the technician must use cables explicitly rated for high-flex or continuous movement. Standard PVC jacketed cables (common for general installations like the KEYENCE PZ-G pre-wired models) will quickly fail under repeated bending, leading to wire breakage and intermittent signal loss. If the cable is routed in a cable track, ensure the bending radius adheres to the cable manufacturer’s specifications to prevent conductor fatigue.

---

11. Maintenance and Long-Term Reliability: Troubleshooting Core Issues

Long-term reliability hinges on consistent preventive maintenance and a structured troubleshooting approach.

11.1. Standardized Cleaning Procedures

The SICK W4S-3’s stainless steel housing and sealed design are intended to withstand high-pressure washdown. However, inappropriate cleaning practices can still cause premature failure.

• Lens Integrity: Avoid using abrasive materials that could scratch the sensor’s lens, as scratches significantly reduce the light transmission and signal margin. Use non-aggressive cleaning agents and a soft cloth to maintain optimal sensor performance.
• Chemical Compatibility: Even for IP69K-rated sensors, confirming the sensor housing material (e.g., V4A/316L Stainless Steel for SICK) is chemically compatible with the facility's specific cleaning agents is paramount to prevent stress cracking or seal degradation over time.

11.2. The Logical Flow for Sensor Troubleshooting

When a machine fault log indicates a sensor error, the field technician follows a clear decision tree:

• 1. Check Power: Is the Power LED (Brown and Blue wires) illuminated? If not, check the fuse or connection at the power supply.
• 2. Check Sensing Target: Is the target present and correctly positioned within the sensor's range? Is the target's surface clean?
• 3. Check Output/Alignment: Does the Output LED (Black wire) change state when the target is introduced/removed? If it remains off when it should be on, adjust the sensitivity (KEYENCE) or run the teach-in routine (SICK) to regain the margin.
• 4. Check Wiring: If the sensor LED indicates correct operation but the PLC input is off, use a multimeter to measure the voltage on the Black wire. If the voltage is present but the PLC is not reacting, the issue lies in the wiring run (breakage, short) or the PLC input card itself.

If the sensor is clean, powered, and correctly aligned, but still exhibiting intermittent behavior (often due to noise), the diagnosis moves back to Section 4: Shielding and Grounding. The problem is almost never the sensor itself; it is the environment or the installation.

---

12. Conclusion: Making the Final Installation Choice

Choosing between sensors like the SICK W4S-3 and the KEYENCE PZ-G for installation ultimately comes down to environmental priorities.

The SICK W4S-3 Inox requires a more rigorous installation process, often involving hygienic mounting brackets and careful M12 connector torque, but it offers unparalleled longevity and reliability in extreme washdown, chemical, and temperature environments. Its robustness minimizes the frequency of replacements and maintenance in demanding applications.

The KEYENCE PZ-G provides a rapid, flexible, and simple installation, making it the superior choice when speed of deployment, ease of adjustment, and general-purpose reliability are the highest priorities on the factory floor. Its accessible trimmer and clear switching modes simplify initial setup and quick field modifications.

The skilled technician integrates both knowledge of the sensor's specific wiring requirements (PNP/NPN, shield grounding) and its operational features (BGS, polarization) with meticulous installation techniques to ensure decades of reliable service.

---

Note to Readers: This guide offers technical opinions based on common field applications and should not replace manufacturer documentation. Always consult the official product manuals and local safety codes before performing any electrical installation or maintenance.

The author assumes no liability for any loss, damage, or malfunction resulting from the use or application of this information. Use is strictly at the reader's own risk.