OPTEX BGS-DL10N to BGS-ZL10N: Laser BGS Migration Guide

---

1. Understanding the Necessity for Sensor Migration

The industrial automation landscape is characterized by rapid technological evolution and the necessary retirement of legacy components. This is the reality facing users of the OPTEX BGS-DL10N, a reliable yet discontinued sensor. As this model reaches the end of its life cycle, maintaining machine uptime necessitates migrating to a stable, compatible, and feature-rich successor. The designated direct alternative, the OPTEX BGS-ZL10N, presents a solution that balances continuity with performance enhancement. This guide offers a deep comparison of these two laser sensors, focusing on the practical considerations and crucial differences for a seamless field replacement.

---

2. Core Operational Principles and Sensing Technology

The BGS-DL10N and BGS-ZL10N are both Background Suppression (BGS) sensors utilizing laser technology, engineered for highly precise detection and distance measurement. However, the operational methodologies differ subtly, impacting performance in demanding environments.

2.1. Defining Background Suppression (BGS)

Both sensors use the BGS principle, where a laser beam is projected, and the reflected light is received by a dual-element or segmented photodiode array. The sensor outputs a signal only when the light reflected from the target object falls within a defined range (set distance). Light reflected from the background object is suppressed, preventing false triggers.

2.2. The Impact of Potentiometer vs. Teach Button Setup

The BGS-DL10N relied on a potentiometer for setting the sensing distance. This analog adjustment provides continuous, immediate feedback but can be susceptible to mechanical drift, vibration-induced errors, or tampering in the field. Conversely, the BGS-ZL10N also uses a 4-turn potentiometer for distance adjustment.It is an analog adjustment method, not a digital Teach system, and there is no internal non-volatile memory for taught setpoints. Engineers often prefer the Teach method for its accuracy, especially in high-speed or high-vibration applications.

---

3. Critical Technical Specifications Comparison for Replacement

When replacing a sensor like the BGS-DL10N, field technicians must prioritize physical compatibility and electrical interchangeability. The following table highlights the essential specifications and how they align or diverge between the legacy and the replacement unit.

Characteristic	OPTEX BGS-DL10N (Legacy)	OPTEX BGS-ZL10N (Replacement)	Key Replacement Consideration
Sensing Range	10 to 100 mm	5 to 100 mm	ZL10N offers a shorter minimum distance, which provides flexibility for close-range detection applications.
Light Source	Red Semiconductor Laser Diode (Class 2, IEC/JIS)	Red Laser Diode (Class 1)	Different laser safety classifications (DL10N: Class 2, ZL10N: Class 1), but both use a visible red laser that allows easy visual alignment.
Output Type	NPN Open Collector	NPN Open Collector	Direct electrical compatibility for output wiring, minimizing PLC or controller changes.
Response Time	0.7 ms or less (700 µs or less)	250 µs or less	Equivalent speed, ensuring no performance hit in high-speed processes when migrating.
Power Supply	10-30 VDC	10-30 VDC	Identical operating voltage range, simplifying power supply integration.
Setting Method	4-turn potentiometer	4-turn potentiometer	There is no major functional difference here: both the DL10N and ZL10N use a 4-turn potentiometer for distance adjustment, and neither model uses a digital Teach setup.
Connection	2m Cable (Standard)	2m Cable (Standard)	Direct wiring connection compatibility.
Protection Rating	IP67	IP67	Identical dust and water ingress protection, suitable for the same harsh environments.

Interpretation for Engineers: The transition to the BGS-ZL10N is structurally and electrically benign due to identical NPN output, voltage, and IP rating. The primary operational differences are the shorter minimum sensing distance, faster response time, and Class 1 laser of the BGS-ZL10N. Both models use a physical 4-turn potentiometer for distance adjustment.

---

4. Real-World Deployment Scenario

The choice between these two sensors often crystallizes when considering their application in different material handling environments.

4.1. High-Precision Assembly Line (Cosmetics Packaging)

In a high-speed cosmetics packaging line, the BGS sensor might be used to verify the presence of an internal foam insert within a cap before sealing.

• BGS-DL10N Deployment: Due to the potentiometer setup, setting the precise 30 mm detection range could involve multiple manual adjustments and micro-tuning. If the cap material has slight color variations, the setting might drift over time or require recalibration after maintenance, leading to occasional false negatives (missing an insert).
• BGS-ZL10N Deployment: The ZL10N is adjusted using the 4-turn potentiometer.The technician sets the desired detection point by turning the potentiometer while observing the output and indicator LEDs; there is no Teach-in button or digital teaching sequence on this model. If color variations occur, the ZL10N often exhibits superior color stability due to advanced internal signal processing, resulting in higher reliability and fewer false stops compared to the DL10N in this scenario.

4.2. Automotive Parts Sorting (Detecting Black Rubber)

In the automotive industry, sensors are often tasked with detecting difficult, low-reflectivity materials like black rubber gaskets or dark plastics on a metal conveyor.

• BGS-DL10N Deployment: Black, light-absorbing surfaces present a challenge for BGS sensors. The DL10N would require the potentiometer to be tuned very finely near the stability limit, making it prone to errors if dust accumulates or if the ambient temperature changes, slightly shifting the internal optics.
• BGS-ZL10N Deployment: The ZL10N leverages improved sensitivity and optical design, which is particularly effective with low-reflectivity targets. An experienced technician using the potentiometer adjustment can often achieve a more robust and wider stability margin for detecting black materials compared to the DL10N, leading to fewer mis-sorts and less downtime.

---

5. Installation and Maintenance Notes

The transition from a legacy component to a modern replacement is rarely plug-and-play. Engineers must consider mechanical adjustments and power considerations.

5.1. Mechanical Housing and Mounting Compatibility

The BGS-DL10N and BGS-ZL10N generally share a similar compact housing footprint. However, field experience shows that mounting hole positions can differ by a fraction of a millimeter or the depth of the sensor body may vary slightly.

• DL10N to ZL10N Swap: It is advisable to use the mounting bracket supplied with the new BGS-ZL10N. While the old DL10N bracket might fit, utilizing the new bracket ensures the laser beam alignment is perfectly maintained, which is critical for precision BGS operation. If an existing bracket must be used, the engineer should double-check the beam’s alignment using the visual indicator to ensure the laser spot is centered on the target object.

5.2. Wiring, Power-Up Sequence, and Status Indicators

Both sensors use the standard NPN output configuration, meaning the output sinks current when activated. This makes the wiring replacement straightforward:

– BGS-DL10N (3-wire): Brown = Power (+10–30 VDC), Blue = 0 V, Black = NPN output.

– BGS-ZL10N (4-wire laser type): Brown = Power (+10–30 VDC), Blue = 0 V, Black = NPN output, Gray = Laser OFF input.

• Power Module Replacement: When replacing the sensor, if the power supply module powering the old DL10N is nearing its lifespan, it is good engineering practice to replace the power supply simultaneously. While both sensors operate on 10-30 VDC, the new ZL10N may have slightly different transient current demands during power-up or switching. A fresh power module ensures optimal operating conditions for the new sensor.
• Status Indicators: The ZL10N often features more advanced LED status indicators than the DL10N. Engineers should consult the ZL10N manual to understand the new color codes—for instance, a blinking orange LED might indicate a margin instability warning (the sensor is barely detecting the object), allowing the technician to proactively adjust the position before a catastrophic failure or stop occurs, an early warning feature less pronounced in the DL10N.

---

6. Decision Flowchart for Replacement vs. Upgrade

The choice between a direct replacement and a full-system upgrade is based on the application's complexity, cost constraints, and desired future-proofing. When evaluating the switch from BGS-DL10N to BGS-ZL10N, a condition-based approach offers clarity.

• Condition 1: The machine is legacy, budget is minimal, and the process is simple (e.g., box presence detection).
• Decision: Proceed with the BGS-ZL10N direct replacement. The electrical and mounting compatibility minimizes downtime and integration costs. The only requirement is ensuring maintenance staff understand the 4-turn potentiometer adjustment and the slightly different wiring (including the Laser OFF input on the BGS-ZL10N).
• Condition 2: The process involves complex, highly reflective, or multi-colored targets, and maximum precision is required (e.g., wafer handling).
• Decision: Use the BGS-ZL10N, but consider this a functional upgrade. The improved optical stability and digital setup will provide superior performance margin compared to the DL10N. The investment in the newer sensor is justified by the reduction in false triggers and increase in production reliability.
• Condition 3: The application requires long-range or continuous distance output (analog).
• Decision: Neither the BGS-DL10N nor the BGS-ZL10N is suitable. This scenario necessitates a move to a dedicated high-end laser displacement sensor (e.g., Optex CD33/CD5 series). The two BGS models are primarily proximity/presence sensors with a fixed background cut-off, not precise analog distance meters.

The BGS-ZL10N is the clear and logical path forward for any system currently reliant on the BGS-DL10N, offering superior robustness with minimal mechanical or electrical re-engineering.

---

7. Enhancing Reliability with Advanced Filtering

While the BGS-DL10N performed adequately for its generation, the BGS-ZL10N incorporates refined internal signal processing and filtering that engineers should understand and leverage for enhanced system stability.

7.1. Understanding Digital Noise Reduction

In an industrial environment, electrical noise from motors, Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs), and switching power supplies is common. The ZL10N employs sophisticated digital filtering algorithms to differentiate the true laser reflection signal from environmental noise spikes.

• Practical Impact: An experienced technician might have observed that the DL10N occasionally showed erratic behavior when a large motor started nearby. The ZL10N is significantly more immune to this interference. To maximize this benefit, engineers should still maintain best practices (using shielded cables and separating power/signal lines), but the sensor’s inherent noise immunity adds an extra layer of protection, particularly beneficial in heavily automated zones with dense wiring. This inherent robustness is a major factor driving the preference for the newer model in mission-critical applications.

---

8. Long-Term Reliability and Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF)

For industrial components, especially sensors critical to production flow, the estimated Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) is a key metric. While manufacturers rarely publish direct, comparative MTBF data for superseded models, the technological advancements in the BGS-ZL10N suggest a significantly improved operational lifespan compared to the BGS-DL10N.

8.1. Component Evolution and Thermal Stability

The BGS-DL10N was built using components and processes of its era, which are inherently less robust than modern surface-mount technology (SMT) components. The BGS-ZL10N benefits from:

• Miniaturization and Heat Dissipation: Modern components are smaller and generate less internal heat. Excessive heat is the primary accelerator of electronic component aging, particularly for the laser diode and the internal processing ASIC (Application-Specific Integrated Circuit). The ZL10N's improved thermal management extends the life of these critical internal parts.
• Vibration and Shock Resistance: The adoption of higher-grade SMT solder and advanced component encapsulation in the ZL10N makes it inherently more resistant to mechanical shock and persistent vibration common in industrial settings (e.g., stamping presses or robotic arms), which could loosen connections or stress components in the older DL10N.

8.2. Laser Diode Longevity

Both sensors use a Class 1 visible red laser diode. However, the current generation of laser diodes used in the BGS-ZL10N often have optimized duty cycles and more precise current control circuitry, minimizing thermal stress on the diode junction. This refined control circuitry ensures the laser operates closer to its optimal performance curve, delaying degradation and maintaining stable output power over a longer period. This translates directly to a longer period before the sensor's range begins to drop or its output becomes erratic, a common failure mode for older photoelectric sensors like the DL10N.

---

9. Impact of Enhanced Optical Performance

One of the most significant upgrades in the BGS-ZL10N is the improvement in its optical clarity and receiver performance, which directly impacts its ability to handle challenging targets.

9.1. Minimizing the 'Dead Zone' and Short-Range Stability

The BGS-DL10N had a specified minimum sensing distance of 10 mm. Operating a BGS sensor too close to the background can lead to unstable detection, often referred to as the "dead zone." The BGS-ZL10N pushes this minimum distance down to 5 mm. This 5 mm improvement is critical in applications where space is severely limited, such as in semiconductor equipment or miniature packaging machinery.

• Practical Edge: This reduced dead zone provides engineers with crucial flexibility when mounting the sensor closer to the target object, potentially solving difficult application geometries without resorting to complex optical setups like mirrors or fiber optics, which would have been necessary with the DL10N.

9.2. Color and Gloss Compensation

Color and surface gloss (reflectivity) are the nemesis of standard photoelectric sensors. While the BGS-DL10N performed adequately on matte, neutral-colored surfaces, its performance suffered significantly on highly glossy or intensely dark surfaces.

• The BGS-ZL10N incorporates an ASIC with more sophisticated algorithms for compensating for signal variations caused by different colors and gloss levels. This feature is often referred to as Color Independence or High-Gloss Tolerance.
• Engineering Advantage: In automotive painting lines or electronics manufacturing (where detecting parts on highly polished metal or black-anodized aluminum is common), the ZL10N maintains a stable detection point across a wider range of target materials than the DL10N. When selecting a replacement, if the application involves multiple target colors or finishes, the ZL10N’s superior compensation is a decisive factor for stability.

---

10. Advanced Functionality: Utilizing the ZL10N's Digital Features

Beyond simple replacement, the BGS-ZL10N offers digital features that can be leveraged for enhanced machine diagnostics and operational flexibility, capabilities largely absent in the potentiometer-driven BGS-DL10N.

10.1. External Teach Input

The BGS-ZL10N provides an external wiring pin for a Laser OFF input, not for Teach. This is a game-changer for remotely located or inaccessible sensors.

• Remote Control: Instead of physically reaching the sensor to cycle power or touch the device, an engineer can wire the BGS-ZL10N’s Laser OFF input (gray wire) back to a nearby junction box or, more commonly, to a spare output on the PLC (Programmable Logic Controller) to remotely enable or disable laser emission; this input is not a Teach input.
• Automated Control: This Laser OFF input allows the PLC to automatically disable or enable the laser during specific machine states (for example, during fixture changes or when a safety door is open), improving safety and potentially extending laser diode life, but it does not provide any remote teaching or automatic recalibration function.

10.2. Output Mode Selection (Light-ON / Dark-ON)

While both sensors are available in NPN output, the BGS-ZL10N provides the flexibility to switch between Light-ON (L-ON) and Dark-ON (D-ON) logic via the Light-ON/Dark-ON selector switch on the sensor body, just like the BGS-DL10N.

• Logic Flexibility:
• L-ON: The output turns ON when the target is detected (Light is received).
• D-ON: The output turns ON when the target is not detected (Dark is received).
• DL10N Limitation: The BGS-DL10N has a Light-ON / Dark-ON selection switch on the sensor body, so a single model covers both output logics.
• ZL10N Advantage: Both the BGS-DL10N and BGS-ZL10N have a Light-ON / Dark-ON selector, so a single part number in each series can cover both output logics, simplifying spare parts inventory and providing immediate flexibility during unexpected fault finding where the output logic needs to be quickly inverted to test a new control strategy.

---

11. Maintenance Planning and Lifecycle Management

The shift from the BGS-DL10N to the BGS-ZL10N should be viewed as an opportunity to implement a more forward-thinking Predictive Maintenance strategy, utilizing the data and stability of the new sensor.

11.1. Scheduled Phased Replacement Strategy

Given the large installed base of the discontinued BGS-DL10N, a sudden, complete system overhaul is often impractical. A phased replacement strategy is recommended:

• Criticality Assessment: Identify all machines using the BGS-DL10N. Prioritize replacement for sensors on single points of failure (e.g., primary safety detection, high-speed gating) or in harsh environments (high heat, intense vibration).
• Spare Parts Rationalization: Instead of purchasing diminishing and costly DL10N spares, purchase the BGS-ZL10N as the only spare. When a DL10N fails, the ZL10N is installed, and the wiring and PLC program are updated once.
• Preventive Replacement: Schedule the replacement of all remaining BGS-DL10N units within the next two years, regardless of operational status, to eliminate the risk of unexpected failure and capitalize on the superior stability of the ZL10N.

11.2. Cost-Benefit Analysis: Downtime vs. Investment

While the initial cost of a BGS-ZL10N may be slightly higher than a remaining DL10N spare, the true cost lies in unplanned downtime.

Engineering Principle: If the potentiometer on a legacy DL10N drifts out of tolerance, the resulting two hours of unplanned production stoppage (diagnosis, replacement, manual re-tuning) will invariably cost more than the marginal difference in unit price for the newer ZL10N. The investment in the BGS-ZL10N is not just for a sensor; it is for predictable machine uptime.

---

12. Advanced Troubleshooting: Unique Challenges of Digital Migration

Moving from an older analog-set sensor (DL10N) to a newer analog-set sensor (ZL10N) introduces some new troubleshooting points that field technicians must understand.

12.1. Troubleshooting the BGS-ZL10N Setup

The most common initial failure when migrating to the BGS-ZL10N is an incorrectly adjusted potentiometer setting or incorrect wiring, because this model does not have a Teach procedure.

• Symptom: The sensor output is constantly ON or OFF, regardless of the target presence, and the stability indicator is flashing erratically.
• DL10N Fix (Legacy): Turn the potentiometer until the LED is green.
• ZL10N Fix: The issue is often that the technician has not adjusted the 4-turn potentiometer correctly, or there is a wiring mistake on the power, output, or Laser OFF input. The solution is to readjust the 4-turn potentiometer while monitoring the output and indicator LEDs, following the procedure in the manual for the correct sensing distance and stability margin. If the external Laser OFF input is used, the PLC signal wiring and timing must be verified to ensure the sensor is not being unintentionally disabled.

12.2. Understanding Output Hysteresis

Both sensors have hysteresis (the difference between the turn-on and turn-off point). This is a critical factor for stable switching. Due to its design, the BGS-ZL10N specifies a tighter hysteresis (around 3% versus about 5% for the BGS-DL10N), which improves switching stability, but this hysteresis is fixed by the sensor design rather than being set by any digital teach process.

• Benefit: In the DL10N, the potentiometer setting implicitly controlled hysteresis, often leaving it too loose or too tight, depending on the operator's tuning skill. The ZL10N's automated setting ensures the sensor's switching is maximized for stability and repeatability, eliminating a common source of intermittent errors found in the older manually-tuned units.

---

13. Future-Proofing with the ZL10N Platform

Choosing the BGS-ZL10N is a step toward future-proofing the machine, as the ZL platform is the current standard and provides a foundation for potential future enhancements.

13.1. Platform Consistency

The ZL Series represents the current generation of OPTEX's standard photoelectric sensor technology. Investing in the BGS-ZL10N means that future product upgrades or complementary sensor purchases will likely share the same digital interface and mounting accessories, reducing future training and spare parts complexity. This consistency is a hallmark of efficient lifecycle management in automated systems.

13.2. Preparing for IO-Link

While the basic BGS-ZL10N model does not typically feature IO-Link connectivity, the underlying design platform is often built to support it. Migrating to the ZL-series platform makes the transition to future IO-Link enabled sensors (which provide real-time diagnostic data and remote configuration) much smoother when that technology inevitably becomes standard across the entire industrial floor. This prepares the machine for the principles of Industry 4.0, which the obsolete DL10N could never support.

---

14. Summary of Migration

The migration from the OPTEX BGS-DL10N to the OPTEX BGS-ZL10N is a necessary and highly beneficial upgrade. The ZL10N retains the essential mechanical and electrical compatibility required for a low-cost swap while introducing significant performance enhancements in reliability, noise immunity, color stability, and setup precision via the improved optics, faster response, and 4-turn potentiometer adjustment of the BGS-ZL10N. Field engineers can expect improved machine uptime and reduced maintenance complexity by standardizing on the modern ZL platform.

---

Note to Readers: This information is provided for technical comparison and migration planning. Always refer to the official manufacturer's datasheets and installation manuals before performing any sensor replacement or system modification.

The author assumes no liability for any loss, damage, or malfunction resulting from the use or application of this information. Use is strictly at the reader's own risk.