Yaskawa Sigma-7 vs Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700 Comparison

---

1. Choosing the Optimal Servo System: Precision Versus Integrated Architecture

The selection between YASKAWA SIGMA-7 and Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700/5500 systems hinges on fundamental priorities: is the application constrained by the need for absolute speed and dynamic response (often favoring Yaskawa's pure motion heritage), or is it driven by seamless enterprise-level integration and standardization (where Allen-Bradley excels within the Logix platform)?

Engineers frequently encounter this dilemma when designing high-throughput machinery. If the core requirement is to achieve the fastest possible settling time, minimal velocity ripple, and highest encoder resolution, the SIGMA-7 is generally positioned as the technical benchmark. Conversely, if the machine must be seamlessly integrated into a facility-wide control architecture using the EtherNet/IP protocol and Logix controllers, the Kinetix system offers an unmatched level of unified development and diagnostics.

---

2. Technical Depth: Response Frequency and Encoder Resolution

Comparing the raw technical capabilities of these servo systems provides a foundational metric for machine builders. High-speed response and superior feedback are critical for applications like high-speed packaging, electronic assembly, and cutting systems.

Specification	YASKAWA SIGMA-7 (Example: SGD7S-R90A00A)	Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700 (Example: 2198-D020-ERS3)	Comparison Insight (Experience-Based)
Velocity Loop Bandwidth (Response Frequency)	Up to 3.1 kHz (SGD7S Analog/Pulse Train models)	Up to 400 Hz (Velocity Loop) / 1000 Hz (Current Loop)	Yaskawa shows a significant advantage in maximum achievable velocity loop bandwidth, often translating to faster settling times and higher throughput, particularly in stiff mechanical systems where the loop gain can be maximized without oscillation.
Motor Feedback Encoder Resolution	24-bit Absolute (16,777,216 pulses/rev)	18-bit or 22-bit Absolute (approx. 262k to 4M pulses/rev)	Yaskawa’s higher resolution encoder provides finer positional detail, crucial for ultra-high-precision moves in grinding, vision-guided systems, or laser processing where sub-micron accuracy is a prerequisite.
Primary Motion Network	MECHATROLINK-III (Dedicated Motion Network)	EtherNet/IP (Standard Industrial Ethernet with CIP Motion)	MECHATROLINK-III is a deterministic, proprietary network optimized solely for high-speed motion. EtherNet/IP is an established, open standard that excels in data integration and plant floor communication. The choice dictates the overall control platform ecosystem.
Safety Integration	Standard Built-in STO (SIL 3, PLe). Optional modules for SS1, SS2, SLS.	Standard Built-in STO (SIL 3, PLe). Features Safe Speed Monitoring (SSM) integrated with GuardLogix.	Both meet the highest safety standards, but Allen-Bradley’s approach is typically more deeply integrated into the Logix safety controller environment (GuardLogix).
Multi-Axis Configuration	Separate single-axis amplifiers (SGD7S), or specific dual-axis units (SGD7W)	Multi-axis modules (Dual-Axis 2198-D020-ERS3) sharing a single DC bus and power supply.	The Kinetix 5700 provides a highly compact and efficient DC-bus sharing system, which often leads to smaller cabinet footprints and simpler wiring for multi-axis machines like robots or packaging lines.

---

3. Optimizing Machine Performance: Tuning and Control

The true measure of a servo system’s value is its ability to perform optimally in a real-world mechanical environment, often achieved through sophisticated tuning features.

3.1. Automatic Tuning Capabilities

Both systems feature advanced automatic tuning, but their application methodology reflects their core design philosophies.

• YASKAWA SIGMA-7: Features a highly refined Tuning-less mode and advanced Autotuning. The philosophy is to achieve high dynamic performance with minimal user input. This is particularly valuable when commissioning a machine with varying loads or compliance issues. Engineers often find that for very stiff or high-inertia ratio systems, SIGMA-7’s algorithm provides a stable, high-gain loop faster than competitors.
• Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700: Utilizes Adaptive Tuning within the Studio 5000 Logix Designer environment. This system is heavily integrated with the Logix controller’s processing power. The advantage here is the seamlessness of the tuning process from within the primary development software. An engineer’s decision flow often follows: If rapid deployment using familiar Studio 5000 environment is the priority, Kinetix’s adaptive tuning is the path of least resistance.

3.2. Vibration Suppression and Disturbance Rejection

• YASKAWA's focus on motion dynamics includes advanced features like Velocity Ripple Compensation and multiple user-configurable Notch Filters (up to five) to suppress specific resonant frequencies in the machine structure (e.g., 500 Hz and higher). This allows users to push the system closer to its mechanical limits without oscillation.
• Kinetix leverages the Integrated Compensation features of CIP Motion within the Logix controller, providing effective disturbance rejection and load observation. While powerful, some experienced technicians find that in extremely demanding, high-frequency applications, Yaskawa’s dedicated, amplifier-side filters offer finer control over specific, difficult-to-dampen resonances. The conditional choice here is: If the machine design inherently suffers from complex, multi-frequency mechanical resonance, the dedicated filter bank of the SIGMA-7 offers a superior toolkit for suppression.

---

4. Real-World Deployment Scenario

The differences between these two systems are most apparent when they are deployed in highly divergent industrial settings:

4.1. High-End CNC Machining (Favoring SIGMA-7)

In a High-Speed CNC Machine Tool deployment, the primary metric is contouring accuracy and surface finish. The machine uses a rotary motor on a precision axis for tool path control.

• Metric: Positioning accuracy and high dynamic stiffness.
• YASKAWA SIGMA-7 Deployment: The high 3.1 kHz response and 24-bit encoder resolution are paramount. The machine builder selects the SIGMA-7 to minimize tracking error during rapid acceleration and deceleration along complex tool paths. The Less Deviation Control feature allows the machine to follow the command trajectory with minimal lag, essential for maintaining tight tolerances and producing a pristine surface finish on the workpiece. In this scenario, the proprietary MECHATROLINK-III network is acceptable because the motion controller's singular purpose is achieving the fastest, most precise trajectory generation.
• Quantitative Data: A key performance indicator might be a reduction in the settling time (time to achieve ±1 encoder count) after a major move, where the SIGMA-7 could demonstrate a 20-30% faster settling time compared to a more network-constrained system, depending on the mechanical load.

4.2. High-Volume Packaging Line (Favoring Kinetix 5700)

In a Multi-Axis Cartoning/Packaging Line deployment, the priority is overall system throughput, synchronized data, and ease of line integration. The machine may have 10 to 20 synchronized axes (e.g., feeders, sealers, cutters).

• Metric: Throughput (parts per minute) and overall data availability.
• Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700 Deployment: The system is chosen for its dual-axis module efficiency and the unified EtherNet/IP backbone. All motion and I/O data reside in the Logix controller's tag database, making synchronization with vision systems, safety logic (GuardLogix), and upstream/downstream PLCs extremely simple. Maintenance technicians and engineers can use the Studio 5000 environment for all programming, commissioning, and diagnostic tasks. The dual-axis modules also reduce power component and wiring requirements, minimizing cabinet space by an estimated 10-15% over single-axis-only competitors.
• Quantitative Data: The main benefit is realized through rapid commissioning and troubleshooting. A new axis can be added and its motion profile programmed in less than half the time compared to integrating a third-party servo into a separate controller/network environment, resulting in lower machine build time costs and faster fault resolution.

---

5. Installation and Maintenance Notes

The experience of an engineer on the shop floor, dealing with installation, replacement, and firmware updates, provides a critical lens for comparison.

5.1. Cabling and Connection Philosophy

• YASKAWA SIGMA-7: Traditionally uses a dedicated cable set for power and feedback. While robust and field-tested, the connectors are proprietary. Installation involves routing separate cables for power, encoder feedback, and control I/O. For MECHATROLINK networks, dedicated blue MECHATROLINK cables are required.
• Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700: Emphasizes single-cable technology (for certain motor families) which combines power and feedback into one connection to the motor, dramatically reducing the number of cables required per axis. This is a significant advantage in cable management and troubleshooting during installation, as the potential points of failure (e.g., loose encoder connections) are halved. The use of zero-stack mounting also allows the modules to be mounted side-by-side without a gap, simplifying cabinet assembly.

5.2. Drive Module Replacement and Firmware

• Drive Replacement:
  • Kinetix 5700: Replacement is streamlined by the Logix platform. The drive’s configuration, including motion parameters and scaling, is stored within the Logix controller program, not solely on the drive module itself. An engineer can replace a faulty dual-axis module and have the control system automatically download the configuration from the controller upon power-up, minimizing downtime.
  • SIGMA-7: Configuration parameters are stored within the drive. While Yaskawa offers tools and SD card backups to facilitate parameter transfer, the process is inherently separate from the central PLC program, sometimes requiring an extra step for the technician to ensure correct parameter restoration.
• Firmware Updates:
  • Kinetix 5700: Firmware updates are managed seamlessly through the Studio 5000 Logix Designer environment, typically ensuring compatibility across the entire control system (PLC, HMI, and Drive).
  • SIGMA-7: Updates are managed via separate Yaskawa software (e.g., SigmaWin) and require connection to the drive. Technicians must ensure that the drive firmware level is compatible with the controller firmware, which adds a layer of complexity during machine upgrades. The conditional judgment here is: If system-wide software version control is a major concern, the Logix-integrated solution of Kinetix is much safer for long-term maintenance.

---

6. Communication Architecture and Controller Interoperability

The choice between the MECHATROLINK-III and EtherNet/IP (CIP Motion) communication protocols is perhaps the single most important differentiating factor, determining system scalability and integration ease.

6.1. MECHATROLINK-III (YASKAWA)

MECHATROLINK-III is a high-speed, deterministic motion network. Its strength lies in its very short communication cycle time (down to 125 µs), which directly supports the SIGMA-7’s high-frequency response. It is a closed system optimized for motion and is less susceptible to general network traffic or data collisions.

• Advantage Condition: Highest-speed, synchronized, multi-axis motion is required, and the Yaskawa Motion Controller (e.g., MP Series) is the central motion engine.

6.2. EtherNet/IP with CIP Motion (Allen-Bradley)

Allen-Bradley’s approach uses the standard, commercial EtherNet/IP network, enhanced by the CIP Motion protocol for real-time control. While its cycle time may be slightly slower than a dedicated motion network, its value is in data integration. All motion parameters, diagnostic messages, and I/O status are readily available via standard Ethernet switches and are natively accessible by any Logix controller (CompactLogix, ControlLogix).

• Advantage Condition: Plant standardization, data collection (MES/ERP integration), and simplified control architecture (one network for everything) are the overarching goals.

The experience-driven decision rule for the network: If the application is a standalone machine focused only on maximum dynamic motion performance, choose MECHATROLINK-III. If the machine is part of a larger, connected factory requiring easy data exchange and unified network architecture, choose EtherNet/IP.

---

7. Determining the Selection Criterion: A Flowchart for Engineers

When a design engineer evaluates these two superior systems, the decision is rarely about a single number but about a holistic fit. The selection process can be simplified by focusing on the primary limiting factor of the application.

• If the primary goal is maximizing dynamic performance (e.g., fastest settling time, highest stiffness, minimal velocity ripple): YASKAWA SIGMA-7 is generally the superior choice due to its high-frequency response and 24-bit encoder resolution, making it ideal for precision CNC or semiconductor assembly.
• If the primary goal is seamless system integration, standardization, and simplified maintenance within a Logix environment: Allen-Bradley Kinetix 5700 is the preferred system, capitalizing on single-cable technology, auto-configuration via Studio 5000, and unified EtherNet/IP communication across the entire machine and facility.

Experienced integrators know that using the Kinetix 5700 reduces the complexity of spare parts inventory and training requirements for maintenance staff who are already familiar with the Rockwell Automation ecosystem. However, for the cutting-edge application where the physical limits of speed and precision are being pushed, the raw motion capability of the Yaskawa SIGMA-7 often provides the necessary margin for breakthrough performance. The decision hinges on whether maximum machine performance or maximum operational efficiency and integration is the higher value driver for the specific project.

---

Note to Readers: This content is for informational and educational purposes only, based on publicly available technical specifications and typical industrial applications. Users should always consult official manufacturer documentation and qualified engineers before making critical equipment decisions.

The author assumes no liability for any loss, damage, or malfunction resulting from the use or application of this information. Use is strictly at the reader's own risk.