Delta ASD-B2-1021-B vs Yaskawa SGD7S 1kW Servo Drive Guide

---

1. Application Alignment: Which Servo Meets Your Motion Profile?

The decision between the DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B and the YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A comes down to a fundamental choice between cost-effectiveness paired with reliable general-purpose control and premium performance dedicated to extreme precision and high-dynamic tasks. Both are 1kW-class single-axis servo drives, but their design philosophies target distinct application requirements. An engineer must weigh system inertia, required settling time, and the overall system budget before making a final selection.

1.1 The Crucial Role of Speed Frequency Response

For motion control engineers, the speed frequency response is a primary metric. It dictates how quickly the drive can respond to a command change, directly influencing the machine's throughput and settling time.

The YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A, a member of the Sigma-7 series, is designed for ultra-high performance, boasting a remarkable speed frequency response of 3.1 kHz. This level of bandwidth is crucial for highly dynamic applications like high-speed pick-and-place, semiconductor manufacturing equipment, and precision CNC grinding machines where micro-second timing is essential for quality and speed.

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B focuses on strong, stable performance suitable for the vast majority of industrial applications, such as general packaging, material handling, and simpler indexing tables. While its exact frequency response is not published at the Sigma-7 level, it is generally positioned for applications where the high-bandwidth requirements of 3 kHz and above are not mandatory. Its strength lies in providing rapid, accurate positioning without the premium investment.

If the machine's cycle time is severely limited by motion settling time, or if the load inertia is highly variable and requires aggressive disturbance suppression, the higher response rate of the YASKAWA unit provides a clear technical edge. Conversely, for a system where machine tool cycle times are in the hundreds of milliseconds, the DELTA drive offers a sufficient, stable, and more economical solution.

1.2 Feedback Resolution and Positional Accuracy

Positional accuracy is defined not only by the motor's mechanics but also by the drive's ability to interpret feedback.

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B typically utilizes a 17-bit incremental encoder, providing a feedback resolution of 160,000 pulses per revolution (p/rev). This is a high-resolution standard that delivers excellent smoothness and accuracy for most commercial applications.

The YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A is typically paired with a 24-bit absolute encoder, delivering a feedback resolution of about 16 million pulses per revolution. This offers significantly finer control over the motor shaft's position. Furthermore, the absolute encoder eliminates the need for homing routines after a power cycle, simplifying machine startup—a significant operational advantage in complex systems.

When the application demands sub-micron or micro-radian level precision, such as in optics alignment or specialized metrology equipment, the superior encoder resolution of the YASKAWA system becomes the necessary technical requirement.

---

2. Specification Analysis: Core Hardware Differences

Comparing the raw technical data of these two servo drives highlights the differences in their intended use environments and performance capabilities. This table re-structures the specifications from an engineer's operational perspective.

Operational Specification	DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B (1.0kW)	YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A (1.5kW)
Primary Motion Control Focus	General Precision & Cost-Effectiveness	Ultra-High Dynamic Performance & Precision
Typical Output Power (Rated)	1.0 kW	1.5 kW (Max. applicable motor capacity)
Input Voltage & Phase	Single-Phase / Three-Phase 200-255 VAC	Three-Phase 200-240 VAC
Speed Frequency Response	Standard Industrial Grade (Sufficient for most tasks)	3.1 kHz (Industry-leading, ultra-high dynamic)
Standard Encoder Resolution	17-bit Incremental (160,000 p/rev)	24-bit Absolute (~16,000,000 p/rev)
Tuning Modes	Auto-tuning, Manual Tuning	Advanced Auto-Tuning, Vibration Suppression, Ripple Compensation
Communication Interface	Pulse + Direction, Analog Voltage	Analog Voltage, Pulse Sequence
Safety Function	Basic (Dependent on External Safety Relay)	Integrated STO (SIL 3, PL-e Cat. 3); SS1, SS2, SLS available via Sigma-7 safety option modules

---

3. Real-World Deployment Scenario

The deployment scenario dictates which drive offers the greatest long-term value and operational simplicity.

3.1 Scenario A: Mid-Range Packaging Line (DELTA Advantage)

Consider a standard horizontal form fill seal (HFFS) packaging machine used for food products. This machine requires coordinated motion for film feeding, sealing jaw actuation, and product indexing. The primary requirements are high repeatability, moderate speed (e.g., 60-80 cycles per minute), and strong tolerance to the facility’s voltage fluctuations.

DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B Deployment: The DELTA drive is ideal here. Its solid 17-bit resolution is more than adequate for the required positional accuracy of the sealing jaws. The single-phase input capability on its 1kW class is often a critical advantage in older or smaller facilities where 3-phase power is not easily accessible at every control panel. The drive provides a robust and reliable workhorse solution without incurring the extra cost of features like a 3.1 kHz bandwidth that the mechanical limitations of the packaging machine could never fully utilize. The simpler programming structure also reduces commissioning time for PLC programmers familiar with basic pulse/direction control.

3.2 Scenario B: High-Precision Laser Engraving System (YASKAWA Advantage)

Consider a machine designed for high-speed, high-accuracy laser engraving on metal surfaces, requiring extremely fine-grained control over the X-Y gantry position to ensure perfect geometric reproduction. The system operates on a gantry with very low mechanical friction and demands high acceleration and deceleration profiles.

YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A Deployment: The YASKAWA drive is the superior, necessary choice. The 3.1 kHz speed frequency response is critical for rejecting high-frequency disturbances and ensuring the gantry settles in position instantaneously before the laser fires, maintaining the required nanometer-level precision. The 20-bit absolute encoder feedback ensures that the machine's coordinate system is always maintained, even after emergency stops, eliminating the time-consuming re-homing process common with incremental systems. In this scenario, the initial investment in the higher-performing YASKAWA is justified by the resulting product quality and throughput speed.

---

4. Installation and Maintenance Notes

Field engineers encounter distinct differences between the two architectures during installation and routine maintenance, largely concerning setup, fault diagnosis, and safety integration.

4.1 Wiring and Initial Configuration

DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B: The installation procedure is straightforward, often relying on simplified parameter sets. The drive uses standard connectors and the wiring logic is clear. A common field note is to ensure the correct filter and reactor are used when utilizing single-phase power, as this can affect noise suppression. The auto-tuning feature is effective for basic mechanical loads, but an experienced engineer will still manually tweak gain settings for systems with higher or lower inertia to achieve optimal stiffness.

YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A: Wiring the Sigma-7 drive often involves connecting the built-in Safe Torque Off (STO) terminals. This is a critical point: while the DELTA drive requires an external safety relay to achieve a PLe/SIL 3 safety rating, the YASKAWA unit has the safety function internally. This simplifies the control panel wiring, reducing external component count but requiring the control wiring to be carefully integrated into the machine's safety circuit according to the provided schematics. Initial configuration relies on highly sophisticated auto-tuning algorithms that often require minimal manual adjustment, simplifying the setup for complex load profiles.

4.2 Firmware Updates and Troubleshooting

DELTA: Firmware updates are typically managed through a dedicated utility and PC connection. Error codes are generally mapped to physical faults (e.g., overcurrent, overvoltage). A common troubleshooting experience is resolving oscillation, which is often solved by slightly reducing the position loop gain or adjusting the velocity loop filter parameters. The software interface is designed to be intuitive for a programmer focused on fast deployment.

YASKAWA: Troubleshooting benefits from the drive's built-in diagnostics, which can provide more granular data on motor load, vibration, and torque ripple suppression. This advanced data is invaluable for diagnosing intermittent mechanical issues that might not immediately trigger a hard fault. Firmware management, while robust, often follows a more structured, release-controlled process. A significant difference in maintenance is the integrated regenerative resistor option or the simplified connection for an external one, making energy dissipation less complex in high-deceleration cycles compared to the more externalized approach often required by the DELTA system.

---

5. Total Cost of Ownership and Ecosystem Consideration

Beyond the initial purchase price, a long-term deployment must consider the surrounding software, hardware, and integration costs.

5.1 Software and Programming Environment

The choice of drive dictates the subsequent learning curve and software investment for the engineering team.

The DELTA drive’s software is typically viewed as accessible and straightforward, with a focus on immediate functionality. The setup is fast, and the feature set is comprehensive for general motion tasks. The simplicity of the pulse/direction interface allows for easy integration with a wide variety of PLC platforms, making it highly flexible in multi-brand automation environments.

The YASKAWA drive is supported by a robust, highly sophisticated suite of programming and simulation tools. These tools are necessary to take full advantage of features like advanced vibration suppression and ripple compensation. While the learning curve may be steeper, the software capability allows engineers to simulate complex movements and optimize the machine's performance virtually before physical commissioning, significantly reducing on-site tuning time for intricate applications. This software depth adds value in environments prioritizing system optimization.

5.2 System Scalability and Integration

When a system needs to scale to many axes, the YASKAWA platform, particularly when opting for the EtherCAT communication models (an option within the Sigma-7 family), offers a superior path for synchronous, high-speed, multi-axis coordination—a necessity for advanced robotics or high-end machine tools.

The DELTA drive's strength lies in its ability to be seamlessly dropped into existing systems using conventional I/O or basic fieldbus communication, often serving as a reliable upgrade for older, less powerful servo systems without requiring a complete overhaul of the control architecture.

---

6. Advanced Torque Control and Disturbance Rejection

The capability of a servo system to maintain control stability under dynamic load changes and mechanical resonance is a critical differentiator for experienced engineers. This capability is rooted in the architecture of the control loops and the sophistication of the filtering algorithms.

6.1 Internal Control Loop Architecture

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B employs a robust current-velocity-position cascade control loop structure, which is the industry standard for reliable servo operation. Its primary strength in control stability is achieved through solid proportional-integral-derivative (PID) tuning across the velocity and position loops. Field application experience shows that optimal performance is typically achieved when the engineer carefully matches the motor's moment of inertia to the load and then slightly detunes the gain parameters to prevent mechanical oscillation on less rigid machinery.

The YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A utilizes a more advanced, proprietary control architecture that includes specialized control modes designed to handle high-inertia mismatches and unpredictable disturbances. This includes dedicated filters and observers that estimate and compensate for mechanical variations in real-time. For instance, its ability to use up to six programmable notch filters allows engineers to precisely suppress multiple specific resonance frequencies inherent in a machine's structure—such as those created by long transmission belts or flexible couplings. The DELTA system offers a more limited number of filters, meaning that while it handles common resonance effectively, it may struggle with machines exhibiting complex or multiple resonance points.

6.2 Mechanical Vibration and Ripple Compensation

YASKAWA's focus on precision includes built-in functions for ripple compensation and mechanical vibration suppression. Torque ripple, a cyclic variation in motor torque caused by magnetic or commutation effects, is a major impediment to ultra-smooth motion. The SGD7S drive actively monitors and compensates for this ripple, which is essential for applications like optical scanning or printing where speed consistency is paramount. Furthermore, its vibration suppression algorithms actively dampen low-frequency vibrations caused by the mechanical structure, significantly improving the settling time and overall machine smoothness.

The DELTA system relies more on standard electronic dampening techniques. While effective for most industrial tasks, it requires the engineer to manage vibration primarily through the mechanical design (e.g., using rigid frames or anti-vibration mounts), whereas the YASKAWA system can actively mitigate deficiencies in the mechanical structure through its software, offering a substantial advantage in achieving high performance on moderately rigid platforms.

---

7. Communication Protocols and Future-Proofing

The communication capabilities of the servo drive dictate its versatility, its suitability for data acquisition (IoT/Industry 4.0), and the overall cost of the control system infrastructure.

7.1 The Pulse/Direction Standard vs. Fieldbus Options

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B primarily operates using the traditional Pulse and Direction interface, and Analog Voltage command. This method is universal, reliable, and requires minimal setup complexity, making it highly preferred for simple, point-to-point positioning applications driven by a dedicated motion control card or a basic PLC pulse output. However, it requires dedicated I/O for every axis and lacks the intrinsic diagnostic data streaming that modern fieldbus networks offer.

The YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A is available in a variety of versions that support leading industrial Ethernet protocols, such as EtherCAT, Mechatrolink-III, and PROFINET. While the specific model SGD7S-120A00A mentioned is the base Pulse/Analog version, the Sigma-7 family platform is designed for these high-speed deterministic networks. When selecting a fieldbus-enabled Sigma-7 model, the benefits are immense: high-speed, synchronized multi-axis control over a single cable, reduced wiring complexity, and the ability to stream diagnostic data directly to the PLC or a monitoring system.

7.2 Data Acquisition and Remote Diagnostics

For companies looking to future-proof their machinery by integrating it into a digital ecosystem, the fieldbus capabilities are non-negotiable.

Using the YASKAWA drive with an EtherCAT or PROFINET connection allows the machine builder to remotely monitor parameters such as motor temperature, torque usage, and instantaneous power draw. This data is crucial for implementing predictive maintenance strategies, where a declining motor health can be flagged before catastrophic failure occurs. The higher data rate and comprehensive parameter access make it a powerful tool for sophisticated machine monitoring.

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B, when utilized in its Pulse/Direction form, requires engineers to develop custom logic in the PLC to infer operational status from discrete I/O signals, which is a less granular and more resource-intensive method of data acquisition. While robust, this reliance on I/O limits the amount of high-fidelity diagnostic data that can be collected for Industry 4.0 initiatives. Therefore, if data-driven decision-making and remote monitoring are high-priority design goals, the YASKAWA platform offers a clearer, more powerful path forward.

---

8. Decision Flow: Choosing the Optimal Servo Drive

The final choice rests on a structured assessment of the application requirements and the project's economic constraints.

If the project prioritizes maximum cost efficiency and the primary task involves standard point-to-point positioning, indexing, or linear movement where settling time is not the critical bottleneck (e.g., general packaging or dispensing):

The DELTA ASD-B2-1021-B is the optimal choice. It provides industrial-grade stability, excellent positional repeatability, and a sufficient 17-bit resolution, delivering the best value and simplest integration for the widest range of common automation tasks.

If the project demands the highest levels of performance, requires sub-micron precision, involves high-frequency motion profiles, or operates in a highly variable load environment (e.g., semiconductor, laser cutting, or high-speed printing):

The YASKAWA SGD7S-120A00A is the necessary selection. The 3.1 kHz bandwidth, 20-bit absolute encoder, integrated safety functions, and superior disturbance rejection capabilities directly translate into a reliable performance envelope required for high-end, dynamic machine control. The higher initial investment is offset by reduced maintenance (no homing required), higher throughput, and superior product quality achievable through finer control.

Engineers should first define the maximum acceptable settling time and the minimum required positional accuracy for their machine. If these metrics fall within the robust capabilities of the DELTA B2 series, choosing it allows the budget to be reallocated to other critical machine components. If the metrics exceed standard industrial requirements and venture into the high-dynamic realm, the superior technology of the YASKAWA Sigma-7 series is warranted.

---

Note to Readers: This article offers technical insights for comparison purposes only; machine performance is dependent on specific application parameters. Always consult official product documentation for detailed specifications and safety guidelines.

The author assumes no liability for any loss, damage, or malfunction resulting from the use or application of this information. Use is strictly at the reader's own risk.